I’m sure by now most of you have seen Oklahoma State football coach Mike Gundy have kittens at a postgame news conference on Saturday after a columnist penned a piece critical of one of his players. If you haven’t seen it, do yourself a favor and scoot over to youtube to check it out. It knocks Colorado coach Dan Hawkins’ “play intramurals, brother!” rant out of the top spot on the list of most entertaining coaching meltdowns.
While the journalist in me isn’t in love with the fact that Gundy called most of The Oklahoman columnist’s Jenni Carlson’s column “fiction” without backing it up with specific examples (in the same way I’m not nuts over that fact that so much of Carlson’s piece cited “rumblings” and “stories told on the sly”), his rant did have some merit.
If you chose to play football (or any high-profile sport) at a major college, you may not have the enormous paycheck of your professional counterparts, but you do have a scholarship, a certain level of notoriety and plenty of perks that aren’t available to most of your classmates. As a result, you must develop a thick skin and be able to take criticism.
College sports fans have an increasingly insatiable appetite for information and college athletics departments have had an increasingly insatiable appetite for donations. Combine those two forces and it shouldn’t come as a shock that the media isn’t shying away from asking tough questions.
Bottom line, if a columnist claims you don’t have the guts to lead a team, prove them wrong or, if your feelings are too hurt, go play D-III.
However, once you get past the bright lights of major college or pro athletics, the lines between who is open for criticism and who isn’t becomes blurry.
I’ve been in situations where I’ve had to toe that line, and it’s rarely simple. Short of running afoul of the law or outright cheating, it can be tough to figure out when criticism is appropriate.
The coaches I deal with on the preps beat usually don’t just coach. While coaches like Butch Davis and Mike Krzyzewski are allowed to live, eat, sleep and breathe their sports, guys like Western Alamance’s Hal Capps and Cummings’ George Robinson spend their days teaching classes and grading papers. Sports come later. Both college and high school coaches usually have spouses and kids, but guys like Eastern Alamance’s John Kirby and Southern Alamance’s Jason Smith don’t have the seven-figure salaries to make those late nights and lost weekends easier.
The players I deal with have parents and siblings. They have classmates and homework. High school can be hard enough without some guy from the newspaper making it harder.
I have always tried to take that in account when I write about them.
So when I hear Gundy rip into a columnist for painting a less-than-flattering picture of an amateur athlete, on some level, he may have a point.
That said, I’ve won exactly no Pulitzers and have never been approached to teach a class on journalism ethics, so take my thoughts for what their worth. If you have a problem with them, you come after me. I’m a man. I’m 28.
Anyway, here are a few thoughts on this week’s games.
WESTERN ALAMANCE AT ROCKINGHAM COUNTY
Western Alamance’s Hal Capps said the Cougars feature a straight-forward offense but will mix in trick plays. They might need to hit on more than a few to keep up with the top-ranked Warriors.
CEDAR RIDGE AT EASTERN ALAMANCE
Eastern Alamance will only have to play one game this week. After enduring two games last week, the Eagles will no doubt enjoy the return to normalcy.
NORTHEAST GUILFORD AT SOUTHERN ALAMANCE
With the Rams bringing in their tricky option attack, Southern Alamance coach Daniel Barrow will call upon his decades of knowledge running a similar attack to get his Patriots prepared.
SOUTHWEST GUILFORD AT EASTERN GUILFORD
Eastern Guilford will aim to keep its momentum going in its final pre-conference tune-up.
RAGSDALE AT EASTERN RANDOLPH
Tommy Norwood and Burton Cates have forgotten more about football than I will ever know.
BARTLETT YANCEY AT GREENSBORO DUDLEY
Bartlett Yancey coach Dennis Bannick said that the last time the Buccaneers traveled to Dudley, traffic jams nearly forced them to miss kickoff. Bannick said there will be no repeat this time.